York & Lancs The Argylls Iraklion map
| |
The third main area of attack was Heraklion with its port facilities and
airfield, assigned to Group East under
Colonel Bruno Brauer, an experienced paratroop commander. This Group was
the strongest of Student's forces, and was made up of the 1st Parachute Rifle
Regiment, the 2nd Battalion of the 2nd Parachute Rifle Regiment and an AA
machine gun battalion. Brauer had a strong force at his disposal, but it
required that it should be deployed in a concentrated and coordinated fashion,
with fighter escort. Unfortunately the schedule for the turn round of
aircraft on the Greek airfields had been over optimistic, as had been the
estimates of transport aircraft that would return from earlier attack
waves. Consequently the transport of Group East was no longer running to
plan. Added to this, as at Rethymnon, the Germans had underestimated the
strength of the defense. While the Germans believed the garrison to be
only some 400 strong, Brigadier Chappel had three British battalions (2nd Black
Watch, 2nd York & Lancs, and the 2nd Leicester), an
Australian battalion, an artillery regiment armed as infantry and three Greek
battalions at his disposal.
As with the rest of the island, there was no fighter cover from the
RAF. In WO 231/3 (Report on Operations, Heraklion Sector) in the
National Archives, para 5 says; "The Preparatory Period 1 May to 19
May. Our own air consisted of one Hurricane and three Gladiators who
spent the nights in RETHYMO. These performed some gallant deeds but
were completely out numbered and were withdrawn about May 18th".
The following is from a report written after the
events of May (WO 231/3 in National Archives):-
"Heraklion Sector The problem
was to protect the town and harbour of HERAKLION, the aerodrome which lay
about three miles to the east of the town, and the beach on which seaborne
landings or crash landings by aircraft might be attempted.
Ten Bofors guns of which six were static and four
mobile were located around the aerodrome. Two sections each of two
field guns were sited to the west and south west of the aerodrome to cover
the aerodrome and harbour. Two companies of the Black Watch, with
one platoon and a section of carriers dug in, were located for the close
defence of the aerodrome. Two 'I' tanks were also concealed
nearby. The remainder of the Black Watch were dug in covering level
ground adjacent to the aerodrome, and one company was given a counter
attack role. Nine 100 mm. and four 75 mm. guns, together with six
light tanks were located south west of the aerodrome.
The remainder of the brigade occupied areas facing
outwards about 2,000 yards from the aerodrome. The town was defended
by one trained Greek battalion and two battalions of Greek recruits.
The Brigade Commander imposed no restrictions on
opening fire by AA guns but all else was to be concealed until the
preliminary bombardment was over. Each unit was made responsible for
immediate counter attack against parachutists in its own area. Tanks
and reserves as ordered by the Brigade Commander were to emerge and deal
with parachute landings and troop carriers. The field guns were not
to open fire on the aerodrome until ordered. The intention of the
Brigade Commander was to give this order only if troop carriers landed in
numbers or the anti aircraft guns were knocked out.
Rations for five days were issued to each unit and
detachments were told to hold water on the scale of one gallon for six
days."
One of those who died on the first day of the fighting was Private Joe
Miller of the 2nd Black Watch. (Info was in an email from Hank
Paterson who knows Joe Miller's relatives, they recently paid a visit to
Crete and Athens.)
From the information on the Argylls,
these forces were disposed as follows; Black Watch on the extreme left,
2/4 Australian battalion left centre, the Leicesters right centre, and the
York & Lancs on the right. The Greek troops extended the York
& Lancs right flank to the coast. Added to this were six light tanks and two
(I) tanks. During the night of the 24/25th May they were joined by a
battalion of the Argyll & Sutherland
Highlanders who been landed at Tymbaki on the night of the 18th May.
Keeping 'tabs' on the tanks during the action, in all three sectors, is
not easy from the books I have been using. In WO 231/3 there is
mention of two 'I' tanks going from Heraklion sector to Suda Bay; "Diary
of major events. 23rd May. Two 'I' tanks arrived from TYMBAKI
about midday. They had forced their way through the enemy position
on the TYMBAKI road..... These two 'I' tanks with the one remaining mobile
in the sector, were sent after dark by lighter with two 75mm guns to
SUDA."
|
|
Like Campbell at Rethymnon, Chappel assigned the
defense of the town to the Greek forces, around this he positioned his other
troops. The defensive perimeter was a semi-circle with the artillery in their
infantry role to the west, along with the Leicesters and the York and
Lancs. In the centre of the perimeter were two hills called the Charlies
occupied by the Australians and overlooking the airfield. East Hill
overlooked the airfield from the east, and was defended by the Black Watch.
The Bofors guns were dug into gun pits around the perimeter while the field guns
at his disposal were positioned close to the "Charlies", and ranged on
the airfield. Chappel also had two "I" tanks, one at each end of
the airfield, and six light tanks by East Hill. The strategy was not to
give away their positions until the Germans had landed in strength, then hit
them with concentrated fire.
|
|

|
|
|
|
The airfield with
the "Two Charlies" and East Hill (to the east of them)
.
|
|
|
 |
The Ju52 transport
aircraft over Heraklion, one of them on fire. On the left of
the photo is a triple 'chute which is presumably for supplies of
some sort. |
|
|
|
|
As with the other attacks further west, the troop transports were preceded by
an air attack on the airfield by Stukas from Scarpanto. As at Rethymnon the
JU52s came in
low, starting their drops at around 17:00, many of the German attackers died on their way to the ground, or before they
could recover their weapons from the containers. Burckhardt's 2nd
Battalion of German paratroops was almost wiped out. In Heraklion itself the
Germans were having an equally bad time. The Cretans and the Greek
battalions were not giving up the town without a hard fight. Major Shultz
and his men were involved in intense street fighting until they were forced to
withdraw.
From WO 231/3 in the PRO; "Meanwhile the
defences at HERAKLION had been subjected to a heavy bombardment from 16.00
hrs to 17.00 hrs. and it is estimated that about four battalions of
parachutists were then dropped on the areas west and south of the town,
north and south of the road leading along the aerodrome, and in the valley
east of the aerodrome. In accordance with the Brigade Commander's
plan, immediate counter attacks were launched by all, including Sector
Headquarters, tanks, and Greeks. All areas inside the British
perimeter were clear of the enemy by 2130 hrs. and extremely heavy
casualties had been inflicted on the enemy. Fighting continued in
the town and on the outskirts throughout the night."
|
|
|
Colonel Brauer, Commander of Group East, with the 1st Battalion, landed
around 8 p.m., and with little knowledge of the tactical situation, made an
optimistic report back to HQ, just as Group West had done earlier regarding
Maleme. He was surprised to find that his forces did not in fact hold the
airfield, and so he decided to hold fast until the morning when he could call on
air support. |
As at Rethymnon, the Germans around Heraklion were not successful
on the 21st, when they tried to take the town and airfield. For the next
week they kept the German forces at bay. Unfortunately their ascendancy
over their attackers was not put to good use by Creforce HQ. At Heraklion
and Rethymnon the German attacks had been beaten off, but there was no attempt
to join these Allied groups and clear the Germans from the area between these
two towns. Everything was hinging on events around Maleme. |
|
|
| By the 25th the Germans believed that they
needed to send in more troops to Heraklion, especially as they were aware
that some Hurricane fighters had been flown in to the airfield (they might
not have been aware that they were damaged). For the action on the
25th and the involvement of the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders, see
the separate page. |
|
|
| The report on Heraklion raised on 4th June 1941
contained some comments from Brigadier Chappel, especially on the issue of
the lack of air cover;
"Nearly all commanding officers commented to
me on the difficulty of making the soldier understand why he was left
unsupported by the air, when the BBC, and Press, talk so freely of the
large number of additional aircraft which have been received. Troops
actually round the aerodrome felt this particularly."
And in another section of the report; "RAF.
It is submitted for serious consideration that the soldier will not stand
indefinitely under continuous enemy air action with no sight of his own
air support. ... The men were asking why we had no air; this it was
possible to answer by saying that needs elsewhere were greater, but I feel
that regrettable incidents may occur if Bns. [sic] are called on to sit
under continuous air attack with no hope of support from our own
air." These views were similar to those expressed all
over the island, and many had been heard previously in Greece. |
|
|
| Brigadier Chappel had some comments in the
report in WO 231/3 on the events at the end of the action. "The
Greeks and Cretans, after their gallant performance, will be treated hard
and will feel that we have left them in the lurch. A great majority,
particularly of Cretans, will continue fighting, but food is going to be a
problem: will it be possible for us to help them in this respect?"
And a comment on the end game; "The general
result of German operations was that on May 28 our perimeter was
intact. We were hemmed in on West, South & East but the harbour
and town were in our hands. The roads to the west could have been
opened with our existing forces, but only at the expense of the weak bn.
[sic] in reserve, which would have had to be retained in that area where
parachute landings were common. The road to the south could not be
opened without reinforcement, and the commanding ground to the south and
east were definitely in enemy hands with gun positions prepared and a
force of at least 4 bns. (estimated) ready for an attack on our position.
It is my considered opinion that that attack would
have been delivered on May 29th and that it would have been directed on
the eastern defences of the aerodrome. These would have been over
run." |
|
|
|
|
| In June 2004 the Times Newspaper ran
an obituary for Group Captain Tony Trumble, OBE. He was a Squadron
Leader during the invasion of Crete., having flown Skuas from carriers, as
well as Hurricanes. He had been C.O. of 261 on Malta. "In
1941 Trumble was posted to Cairo, and then to Crete, where he became
station commander at RAF Heraklion just as the Germans invaded the island
in May. When the station was overrun by airborne troops, he was
captured. |

|
| He then spent the next four
years in captivity, at first in Crete and latterly at Stalag Luft III at
Sagan in Silesia. As a wing commander he was for a time the senior
camp officer, responsible for the welfare of Allied prisoners, and after
his return to Britain he was appointed OBE in December 1945 for his
inspiring leadership among the prisoners of war. he went on to fly
Meteors after the war." |
|
| The following is a statement by Major Burckhardt,
a paratrooper, who was later captured on the Alamein front, but fought at
Heraklion. The statement is from WO 231/3 in the National Archives.
Major BURCKHARDT of the Luftwaffenjagerbrigade 1 was captured on the
Alamein front on Nov. 5th '42.
He stated he was in command of a Bn. of the Air
Division which in company with two other Bns. made the parachute landing
at Heraklion.
For some days beforehand he had studied air
photographs and intelligence reports of the objective he had to take, and
he had come to the conclusion that there were no tanks, carriers or A/A
guns to be reckoned with. For this reason he took no A/Tk weapons.
It had been intended that the parachute attack
should be immediately preceeded by a heavy Stuka raid, in order to stun
the defenders, but according to BURCKHARDT bad staff work crept in and the
Stukas arrived far too early - at all events the defenders were not
stunned. [see comment below J Dillon] He maintains that owing to this the Bren gunners were ready
for him, and he lost two of his JU 52s before the men could jump.
When the Bn. landed they found not only half a
dozen tanks waiting for them but also sixteen Bren carriers. "The
camouflage of these A.F.Vs had been perfect. I had been sure when we
jumped that we should have only infantry to deal with. That was my
first surprise. The second was when I discovered who the Infantry
were."
No sooner had the parachutists landed than the
infantry were upon them, and many of them were killed before they could
get to the containers in which their arms had been dropped. As soon
as he could get a wireless set going BURCKHARDT asked for A/Tk weapons to
be sent, but although these arrived they were once again unable to reach
the containers, and few if any, of the A/Tk weapons ever came into
action. "The Jocks quickly grasped the importance of these
little cylinders, and seldom allowed us to come near them."
The battle continued with great ferocity for two
days and the Bn. suffered very heavy casualties. "I had never
expected such bitter fighting and we began to despair of ever gaining our
objective, or indeed of surviving at all. The Bren carriers were
particularly dangerous to us, for they were not so blind as the tanks, and
faster, and we had no armour piercing weapons. The only thing to do
was to ambush and storm each one separately, jumping on them and killing
the crew with machine pistols. They never surrendered. In this
way we destroyed twelve carriers, but for each one I lost at least twenty
men, sometimes more. Had it been any other regiment but the Black
Watch - any other - all would have been well. Eventually we
were at our wits end. I had but 80 men left of my original 800, no
food, little ammunition, and was no nearer success. The Jocks were
eating our food. Next morning I received the biggest surprise of an
astonishing battle. They had all gone in the night."
The above statement was received on 13.12.42 from Brig. N. McMicking,
D.S.O. O.B.E., 13th Corps, Libya. |
| The above comments reinforce comments elsewhere
on the site that the intelligence briefings given to the German troops was
wide of the mark in terms of numbers to expect on the ground, and the
strength of the defence they would meet.
Burckhardt comments that the transports arrived
after the Stukas and blames this on poor staff work. In the 'German
Report Series' that covers the action on Crete it says; "Because
of a delay in the refueling, these planes [transports] arrived too late
over the designated drop points and the paratroops were therefore without
direct fighter and bomber support." Part of the problem
had been the dust at the airfields in Greece which had disrupted all the
flight schedules.
Also from the German Report Series is a comment
on the action around Heraklion on the 28th & 29th. "While
the struggle for western Crete was raging, German reconnaissance planes
reported that a few British planes had returned to Heraklion airfield on
23 May and that reinforcements were arriving by sea in the eastern part of
the island. If complete air superiority over Crete was to be
maintained by the Luftwaffe, the return of British planes en masse
had to be prevented by all means. It was therefore decided the
reinforce the German troops in the Heraklion pocket by dropping hastily
assembled parachute units. They were to take possession of the
airfield and, until relieved by approaching ground forces, prevent the
landing of British planes. Four companies of parachute troops were
formed at Maleme and dropped in the vicinity of the Heraklion pocket west
of the town. Immediately after landing on 28 May, the parachute
units contacted the embattled pocket force and launched a concerted attack
against the British positions, eliminating several enemy strongholds with
the support of dive bombers. After regrouping his forces during the
night the German commander at Heraklion set out to capture the town and
the airfield early on the next morning. At daybreak the German
troops closed in on the British positions. Not a shot was
fired. British naval vessels had evacuated the Heraklion garrison
during the preceding night."
|
|